Featured explainer / READING
Ratings Decoded: how online reviews, star ratings and business scores work
What a star rating can and cannot tell you about a local business
A star rating is a summary of the people who chose to leave a review on one platform, processed by that platform's rules. It can tell you roughly how past reviewers felt. It cannot, by itself, tell you about workmanship, licensing, price, or how the next job will go.
4.8 12 reviews 4.6 900 reviews
Explainers 24
MECHANICS
- How are star ratings calculated on Google, Yelp, Amazon and Trustpilot?
- Why do online reviews disappear or never get published?
- What is the difference between recommended and not recommended reviews on Yelp?
- Why does the same business have different ratings on different sites?
- What does a "verified" review badge actually mean?
- BBB letter grade vs customer reviews: why an A+ can sit beside one star
- Do old reviews still count toward a star rating?
FRAUD
- How do fake reviews get made, and how do platforms catch them?
- What is review gating, and is it allowed?
- Can a business offer a discount or gift for a review?
- How can you tell if a business's reviews have been manipulated?
- Are AI-generated reviews allowed, and how many are being removed?
LAW
- What does the FTC's rule on fake reviews actually prohibit?
- Can a company's contract stop you from posting a negative review?
- Can a business remove a bad review about itself?
- Can a review site be sued over a review or a star rating?
- Which companies has the FTC pursued over fake or suppressed reviews?
READING
- How many reviews does a business need before its rating means something?
- How should you read reviews before hiring a contractor or home service?
- Is a perfect 5.0 rating a red flag?
RESEARCH
Platforms 12
How each headline number is built, from the platform's own pages.
- Google Business Profile 1 to 5 stars
- Yelp 1 to 5 stars
- Better Business Bureau A+ to F letter grade; separate 1 to 5 star reviews
- Trustpilot TrustScore 1 to 5, shown as stars with half steps
- Angi 1 to 5 stars (formerly A to F grades on Angie's List)
- HomeAdvisor Not confirmed from a current HomeAdvisor page
- Thumbtack 1 to 5 stars
- Nextdoor No stars; a Fave count and written recommendations
- Facebook Page rating shown with Recommendations; a separate business rating for purchases after ads
- Houzz Star reviews on professional profiles; scale and formula not stated in the policy
- Tripadvisor 1 to 5 bubbles; separate Popularity Ranking position
- Amazon 1 to 5 stars
Math 6
Worked examples with charts you can check by hand.
- Why 4.8 from 12 reviews is weaker evidence than 4.6 from 900
- A simple confidence-interval explainer for star ratings
- Star rating confidence calculator, with a worked table
- Bayesian averages: what seven phantom reviews do to a rating
- Rounding and the half-star cliff: how 0.01 can change the display
- How much does one review move an average rating?
Glossary 32
Plain definitions, from Bayesian average to Wilson interval.