RATINGS/DECODED

Platforms / BBB

How Better Business Bureau grades and customer reviews work

A BBB profile shows two independent measures. The letter grade is a 100-point score in which 70 points depend on answering and resolving complaints. The star average comes from vetted customer reviews, which the BBB says are not used in the grade. Accreditation is a separate, fee-based status.

Scale
A+ to F letter grade; separate 1 to 5 star reviews
Formula
Published point table; reviews excluded from the grade
Who can review
Named customers with a marketplace interaction; no anonymous reviews
Filtering
Contact details validated; business notified before publication
Asking for reviews
Incentivized reviews not accepted

The Better Business Bureau predates the internet, and its rating system shows it. The central object is the complaint, a dispute a customer asks the BBB to help resolve. Reviews were added alongside and kept apart.

What the number means

What the number means on a BBB profile
You seeWhat it measuresBuilt from
Letter grade, A+ to FHow the business handles complaints and conducts itselfA 100-point scale; see below
NRNo rating: insufficient information or file under reviewNothing; the BBB says NR is not negative
Star average, 1 to 5Opinions of customers who chose to leave a reviewVetted customer reviews only
Accredited sealThe business pays a fee and commits to BBB standardsApplication, fee and a B rating or better
Complaint countDisputes filed through the BBBIndividual complaints, each with a status

The letter grade

The BBB publishes the elements and their point ranges.11 Better Business Bureau, Overview of BBB Ratings

ElementRange
Unanswered complaints40 to 0
Unresolved complaints30 to 0
Complaint volume, weighted by age15 to 0
Time in business10 to 0
Complaint resolution delayed5 to 0
Transparent business practices0 to minus 5
Failure to address a complaint pattern0 to minus 31
Type of business; failure to honor mediation or arbitration; competency licensing; advertising review; BBB trademark infringementeach 0 to minus 41

Scores convert to letters on fixed bands: 97 to 100 is A+, 94 to 96.99 is A, 90 to 93.99 is A minus, and so on down in three-point and four-point steps to F below 60.

"Customer reviews are not used in the letter-grade calculation."11 Better Business Bureau, Overview of BBB Ratings

Because the two largest elements concern whether complaints are answered and resolved, the grade is best read as a responsiveness score. It says little about how often things go wrong and a good deal about what happens next.

Customer reviews

Reviews are star ratings of 1 to 5 with text. The BBB's handling is unusually formal.22 Better Business Bureau, BBB Customer Reviews33 Better Business Bureau, Frequently Asked Questions about BBB customer reviews

  • Identity. The reviewer's email address or phone number is validated. Anonymous reviews are not accepted.
  • Disclosure to the business. "Consumers provide their name, which is shared with the business to help confirm the interaction and allow a response."
  • Pre-publication notice. Reviews are "vetted by BBB and sent to the business before they are published online".
  • No incentives. Reviews tied to discounts, gifts or paid mystery shopping are refused.
  • One or the other. A consumer may file a complaint or a review about an issue, not both.
  • Only two voices. The reviewer and the business may comment; third parties may not.

The BBB adds a plain disclaimer: it "cannot guarantee the accuracy or truthfulness of any single review".

The pages we read do not state how the star average is computed from individual reviews, how long reviews remain on a profile, or how many submitted reviews are rejected.

Complaints versus reviews

The BBB's process page frames the choice. A complaint is for someone who had a marketplace relationship with a business and wants help resolving a dispute. A review shares an opinion. Both "are sent to the business before they're published".44 Better Business Bureau, Process of Complaints and Reviews Only complaints affect the grade.

For a reader, the complaints tab is usually the more valuable half of the profile. Each entry shows what the customer alleged and how the company answered, which is richer than a star.

Accreditation

Accredited businesses commit to eight standards the BBB summarizes as: build trust, advertise honestly, tell the truth, be transparent, honor promises, be responsive, safeguard privacy and embody integrity. "BBB charges a fee for BBB Accreditation", and fees depend on factors including business size. An accredited business must "maintain at least a B rating".55 Better Business Bureau, BBB Accreditation Standards

Accreditation does not appear in the published list of rating elements. A business can hold an A+ without being accredited.

What the BBB does not disclose on these pages

  • The formula for scoring complaint volume against business size.
  • How the review star average is calculated.
  • Rejection rates for submitted reviews.
  • Fee amounts for accreditation.

Reading a BBB profile

Start from the bottom of the scale. An F or a D generally signals unanswered complaints or a serious deduction, and that is concrete. An A+ tells you complaints were answered. Then read the complaints themselves, and treat the star average as a list of how things go wrong for the customers who were upset enough to come here. The fuller argument is in BBB letter grade versus customer reviews.

Questions readers ask

Why does a company with terrible BBB reviews have an A+?

Because reviews are not part of the grade. The grade mostly reflects whether the company responds to and resolves complaints.11 Better Business Bureau, Overview of BBB Ratings

Does the business see my name if I leave a BBB review?

Yes. The BBB says the consumer's name is shared with the business to confirm the interaction.33 Better Business Bureau, Frequently Asked Questions about BBB customer reviews

Is BBB accreditation the same as a good rating?

No. Accreditation is a paid status requiring at least a B rating and adherence to BBB standards. The grade is calculated separately.55 Better Business Bureau, BBB Accreditation Standards

Method Built from five bbb.org pages: the ratings overview, the customer review pages and FAQ, the complaints and reviews process page and the accreditation standards. See how we source and check.

Sources

Every source below was opened and read for this page. Links go to the publisher's own copy.

  1. Better Business Bureau. Overview of BBB Ratings
  2. Better Business Bureau. BBB Customer Reviews
  3. Better Business Bureau. Frequently Asked Questions about BBB customer reviews
  4. Better Business Bureau. Process of Complaints and Reviews
  5. Better Business Bureau. BBB Accreditation Standards