Housekeeping / STANDARDS
Editorial standards: how we source, check and write
Every factual claim on this site comes from a primary source that was opened and read for the page it appears on, and that source is linked beside the claim or in the page's source list. Calculations are ours and are labeled. Where a platform is silent, we say it is silent.
The sourcing rule
A number, a quotation or a statement about what a platform or regulator does must rest on a document we opened ourselves while preparing that page. Recollection does not count, and neither does another website's summary.
Acceptable sources:
- the platform's own help center, policy page, transparency report or press release;
- a regulator's own publication: rule text, staff guidance, a case announcement;
- statutes and regulations in an official or standard legal compilation;
- a court's opinion in the court's published copy;
- a peer-reviewed paper or working paper, via the publisher's or institution's record.
Not acceptable as the basis for a claim: marketing blogs, vendor "statistics" roundups, forum posts, news paraphrases where the primary document is available, and anything we could not open.
If we cannot open a source for a figure, the figure is left out.
How sources appear on the page
Sources are attached at the point of use. On wide screens they sit in the right margin beside the sentence they support. On phones they appear inline, directly after the paragraph. Each page ends with a numbered list of everything it cites.
Quotation marks mean the words are the source's own. Where we shorten, we do not change meaning. Paraphrases follow the source closely enough to be checked against it.
Platform figures are the platform's figures
When Yelp says it removed a given share of reviews, or Google reports how many it blocked, those are self-reported and unaudited. We present them as what the platform reports, name the year they cover, and avoid comparing one platform's count with another's as if they measured the same thing.
"The platform does not disclose this"
Most rating systems are partly secret. When a formula, a weight or a threshold is not published, we say so in those words. We do not infer hidden rules from observation, repeat what consultants claim the algorithm does, or test platforms by posting reviews.
Where we reason beyond the sources, the text marks it: "our inference", "our reading", "we would expect". Those sentences are opinion and should be weighed as such.
Research
Academic findings are reported with their scope: the platform studied, the type of business and, where known, the period. Hotel studies are described as hotel studies. A result about restaurants on one platform a decade ago is not presented as a law of nature. Where papers disagree, both are given.
Allegations
FTC matters that ended in settlement are described as allegations, because they were not tested at trial. Court rulings on motions to dismiss are described as rulings on what was pleaded, not findings of fact.
Worked examples and charts
Everything in the math section is our own calculation. Example review sets are invented, stated in full and labeled as illustrative, so a reader can recompute each figure. Charts are drawn from the numbers on the same page. The calculator runs in the reader's browser and transmits nothing.
Dates
Pages show the month in which their sources were opened. We do not display publication dates, and we do not claim a history the site does not have. Platform policies change without notice; a page is a record of what the sources said in the month stated.
Independence
No platform, business or agency reviews our pages before publication. We accept no payment for coverage, carry no advertising and include no affiliate links. We hold no commercial relationship with any company described on the site.
What we do not publish
- Ratings, rankings or recommendations of businesses.
- Advice on obtaining, removing or countering specific reviews.
- Claims about a named business's review practices, unless they come from a public enforcement record.
- Legal advice.
Corrections
Errors are fixed on the page and recorded on the corrections page with the month of the change. To report one, write to corrections@ratingsdecoded.com.