RATINGS/DECODED

Section / 12 pages

How ratings work on each platform, from its own published rules

One page per platform. Each describes how the headline number is built, who may review, what gets filtered and what the platform does not disclose, using only the platform's own help and policy pages plus public enforcement records.

These twelve systems differ more than their similar-looking stars suggest. Google states a plain average. Trustpilot weights by recency and adds a prior. Amazon uses a model. The BBB grade ignores reviews entirely, and Nextdoor has no stars at all.

Every page carries a "what the number means" table and a list of what the platform leaves unpublished. Where we could not open a current policy page, as with HomeAdvisor, the page says so plainly instead of repeating secondhand descriptions. The comparison table below is assembled from the same sources. For the reasoning behind the differences, read how star ratings are calculated and why ratings differ between sites.

The twelve platforms side by side, from each platform's own published pages
PlatformScaleHow the headline number is builtFiltering
Google Business Profile1 to 5 starsAverage of all published ratings (stated by Google)Automated screening before and after posting; removals are not shown
Yelp1 to 5 starsBased on recommended reviews only; combination method not publishedSoftware sorts each review as recommended or not; staff remove violations
Better Business BureauA+ to F letter grade; separate 1 to 5 star reviewsPublished point table; reviews excluded from the gradeContact details validated; business notified before publication
TrustpilotTrustScore 1 to 5, shown as stars with half stepsRecency-weighted average plus seven neutral 3.5-star reviews; decay weights not publishedAutomated fake-review detection on all reviews; flagging by users and businesses
Angi1 to 5 stars (formerly A to F grades on Angie's List)Described as an average rating; calculation details not publishedChecked before posting; automated verification with staff follow-up in some cases
HomeAdvisorNot confirmed from a current HomeAdvisor pageNot published on any HomeAdvisor page we could openNot confirmed
Thumbtack1 to 5 starsNot publishedPolicy-based removal; time windows; disputes within 30 days
NextdoorNo stars; a Fave count and written recommendationsA count; no average existsAddress registration for members; review-level moderation not described
FacebookPage rating shown with Recommendations; a separate business rating for purchases after adsPage rating method not published; business rating is an average weighted by recency and other factorsCommunity Standards; ratings in violation excluded
HouzzStar reviews on professional profiles; scale and formula not stated in the policyNot published in the Review PolicyPolicy-based; reviewers agree to conditions when posting
Tripadvisor1 to 5 bubbles; separate Popularity Ranking positionRanking uses quality, recency and quantity of reviews; exact algorithm not publishedAutomated screening of every review; human moderation; community reports
Amazon1 to 5 starsMachine-learned models weighing recency, verified purchase and authenticity signalsChecked against Community Guidelines before posting; automated and human checks