RATINGS/DECODED

Explainers / MECHANICS

Why does the same business have different ratings on different sites?

Because each site has different reviewers, different rules about who may post, different filters and a different formula. Studies that matched the same properties across two platforms found only a weak relationship between their ratings.

A contractor shows 4.9 on Google, 3.5 on Yelp and an A+ from the BBB. Nobody is lying. The three numbers were produced by three different machines fed by three different crowds.

Cause one: who is allowed to post

Platforms sit on a line from open to closed.

PlatformPosting rule, as published
GoogleAny signed-in Google account; content must "reflect a genuine experience"
YelpAny account, but the software decides which reviews count
TrustpilotOpen: reviews "can be written at any time" about real experiences, "not just for purchases"
AmazonAccount must have spent $50 in the past 12 months; Verified Purchase labeled separately
ThumbtackReview must rest on "an actual or attempted interaction"; hires made on the platform are badged
NextdoorRegistered neighbors only
BBBNamed reviewers only; the business is contacted before publication

Sources for each row are the platform pages linked at the end of this article.11 Google Maps Help, Prohibited and restricted content, Maps user-contributed content policy22 Trustpilot, Trust Centre33 Amazon Customer Service, Community Guidelines44 Thumbtack Help, Content and Review Policy55 Nextdoor for Business, Small business guide to getting Nextdoor recommendations66 Better Business Bureau, BBB Customer Reviews

Who may post changes what gets posted. The cleanest evidence comes from hotels. Mayzlin, Dover and Chevalier compared reviews of the same hotels on Expedia, where only a customer who booked could review, and on Tripadvisor, where anyone could. Hotels with a strong incentive to fake, independents with single-unit owners, had more positive reviews on Tripadvisor relative to Expedia. Their near neighbors had more negative reviews on Tripadvisor relative to Expedia.77 Mayzlin, Dover and Chevalier, American Economic Review 104(8), 2014, Promotional Reviews: An Empirical Investigation of Online Review Manipulation The open site carried extra praise for some hotels and extra criticism for their competitors, in the pattern that promotional reviewing would predict.

Closed systems have their own tilt. A platform that only invites customers after a completed job never hears from the person whose calls went unanswered. Thumbtack's policy handles this explicitly: a consumer who contacted a pro and got no reply "has attempted to interact" and may leave a review.44 Thumbtack Help, Content and Review Policy Many closed systems do not.

Cause two: who shows up

Each site attracts a different slice of customers. Someone who files with the BBB has usually had a dispute; the organization's own description separates complaints, which seek help resolving a problem, from reviews, which share an opinion.88 Better Business Bureau, Frequently Asked Questions about BBB customer reviews Neighbors on Nextdoor recommend businesses they like, and there is no star scale on which to express mild disappointment.99 Nextdoor Blog, Introducing Local Faves Google reviews can be left in seconds from the Maps app by anyone who walked past.

Self-selection research supports the idea that the mix of who reviews drives the shape of the ratings. A study of 25 platforms found that sites vary in how polarized their review distributions are "on the basis of how selective customers are in reviewing products on the platform".1010 Schoenmueller, Netzer and Stahl, Journal of Marketing Research 57(5), 2020, The Polarity of Online Reviews: Prevalence, Drivers and Implications Fewer, more motivated reviewers produce more extreme distributions.

Cause three: what gets filtered

Yelp sets aside 17% of reviews as not recommended and removes more; those do not count.1111 Yelp Trust and Safety, 2025 Trust and Safety Report Google removes policy violations and averages what remains.1212 Google Business Profile Help, Understand review scores for local places and businesses If a business has been asking customers for reviews, which Google permits and Yelp's software penalizes, its Google count will run far ahead of its Yelp count, and the Yelp reviews that survive will lean toward unprompted ones. Unprompted reviewers are more often the upset ones.

Cause four: the formula

Even with identical reviews, the printed number would differ. Trustpilot weights recent reviews more and adds seven neutral reviews; Amazon uses a model; Google uses a plain average.1313 Trustpilot Help Center, TrustScore and star rating explained1414 Amazon Customer Service, Understanding Customer Reviews and Ratings Our calculation explainer sets these side by side.

How big are the gaps?

Zervas, Proserpio and Byers collected ratings for millions of Airbnb listings and about 700,000 Tripadvisor properties. Nearly 95% of Airbnb properties had an average of 4.5 or 5 stars. Hotels on Tripadvisor averaged 3.8 and B&Bs 4.1. For properties listed on both sites, more received top ratings on Airbnb than on Tripadvisor, and there was "only a weak correlation in the ratings of individual cross-listed properties across the two platforms".1515 Zervas, Proserpio and Byers, Marketing Letters 32, 2021, A first look at online reputation on Airbnb, where every stay is above average

That last finding is the uncomfortable one. Two honest review systems, looking at the same physical property, barely agreed about which properties were better than which.

Which number should you believe?

None alone. A practical order of operations:

  1. Prefer the platform with the most reviews for this particular business, because a larger sample narrows the uncertainty whatever the formula.
  2. Read disagreement as a prompt. If Google says 4.9 and Yelp says 3.5, open Yelp's not-recommended section and Google's lowest reviews. The gap usually has a visible cause: a review-request campaign, a bad month, a dispute.
  3. Keep the BBB grade in its own box. It measures complaint handling and business practices, not customer sentiment. See BBB letter grade versus customer reviews.
  4. Weight closed-platform reviews for authenticity and open-platform reviews for coverage. A badge such as "Hired on Thumbtack" tells you the transaction happened.1616 Thumbtack, How we're committed to your safety Open sites catch the people who never became customers because of how they were treated.

Questions readers ask

Is a Google rating usually higher than a Yelp rating?

We have not found a published, peer-reviewed comparison to cite, so we will not put a figure on it. The mechanics point that way for businesses that request reviews, since Google allows requests and Yelp's software tries not to recommend solicited reviews.1717 Yelp Support Center, Don't Ask for Reviews

Does a big gap between sites mean someone is cheating?

Not necessarily. Different reviewer pools and filters produce gaps on their own. A gap is a reason to read the underlying reviews, and their dates, on both sites.

Method Draws on two published cross-platform studies and the posting rules each platform states on its own pages. See how we source and check.

Sources

Every source below was opened and read for this page. Links go to the publisher's own copy.

  1. Google Maps Help. Prohibited and restricted content, Maps user-contributed content policy
  2. Trustpilot. Trust Centre
  3. Amazon Customer Service. Community Guidelines
  4. Thumbtack Help. Content and Review Policy
  5. Nextdoor for Business. Small business guide to getting Nextdoor recommendations
  6. Better Business Bureau. BBB Customer Reviews
  7. Mayzlin, Dover and Chevalier, American Economic Review 104(8), 2014. Promotional Reviews: An Empirical Investigation of Online Review Manipulation
  8. Better Business Bureau. Frequently Asked Questions about BBB customer reviews
  9. Nextdoor Blog. Introducing Local Faves
  10. Schoenmueller, Netzer and Stahl, Journal of Marketing Research 57(5), 2020. The Polarity of Online Reviews: Prevalence, Drivers and Implications
  11. Yelp Trust and Safety. 2025 Trust and Safety Report
  12. Google Business Profile Help. Understand review scores for local places and businesses
  13. Trustpilot Help Center. TrustScore and star rating explained
  14. Amazon Customer Service. Understanding Customer Reviews and Ratings
  15. Zervas, Proserpio and Byers, Marketing Letters 32, 2021. A first look at online reputation on Airbnb, where every stay is above average
  16. Thumbtack. How we're committed to your safety
  17. Yelp Support Center. Don't Ask for Reviews