Section / 24 pages
Explainers on how reviews, ratings and review law work
Each explainer answers one question, gives the direct answer first, and links every figure to a platform policy page, an FTC document, a court opinion or a published study that we opened and read.
The pieces are grouped by what they are about. Mechanics covers how platforms compute and filter their numbers. Fraud covers how reviews are faked, gated and bought, and how that gets caught. Law covers the FTC's 2024 rule, the Consumer Review Fairness Act and Section 230. Reading is the practical end: what to do with a rating when you are about to spend money. Research summarizes what peer-reviewed studies have measured.
If you are new here, start with what a star rating can and cannot tell you, then how star ratings are calculated. For a single platform's rules, go to the platform pages. For the arithmetic behind small samples, the math section has worked examples and a calculator. Unfamiliar terms are in the glossary.
READING 4
- What a star rating can and cannot tell you about a local businessREADINGA star rating summarizes who chose to review, on one platform, under that platform's rules. Here is what that number supports and what it does not.
- How many reviews does a business need before its rating means something?READINGWith typical spread, 10 reviews pin an average to within about half a star, 100 to within about a fifth and 1,000 to within a twentieth. The reasoning.
- How should you read reviews before hiring a contractor or home service?READINGFor home services, use ratings to rule businesses out, read recent low reviews for patterns, and verify license and insurance separately. A sequence.
- Is a perfect 5.0 rating a red flag?READINGWith a handful of reviews, 5.0 is ordinary and proves little. With hundreds, it is rare enough to ask how the reviews were collected. The arithmetic.
MECHANICS 7
- How are star ratings calculated on Google, Yelp, Amazon and Trustpilot?MECHANICSGoogle uses a plain average. Trustpilot weights recency and adds seven neutral reviews. Amazon uses a model. Yelp counts only recommended reviews.
- Why do online reviews disappear or never get published?MECHANICSReviews vanish when automated filters block them, moderators remove them for policy breaches, or a platform pauses reviews on a page.
- What is the difference between recommended and not recommended reviews on Yelp?MECHANICSYelp's software sorts every review. Recommended reviews set the star rating; not recommended ones stay readable but do not count. How the split works.
- Why does the same business have different ratings on different sites?MECHANICSThe same business can show 4.8 on one site and 3.4 on another because the reviewers, the filters and the formulas differ. What research found.
- What does a "verified" review badge actually mean?MECHANICS"Verified" means something different on Amazon, Trustpilot, Thumbtack, BBB and Nextdoor. What each platform says it checked, and what it did not.
- BBB letter grade vs customer reviews: why an A+ can sit beside one starMECHANICSThe BBB letter grade measures complaint handling and business practices on a 100-point scale. Customer review stars are separate and do not affect it.
- Do old reviews still count toward a star rating?MECHANICSOn Google, published ratings are averaged without a stated time weight. Trustpilot, Amazon, Tripadvisor and Meta say recent reviews count for more.
FRAUD 5
- How do fake reviews get made, and how do platforms catch them?FRAUDMost fake reviews are written by the business itself or people tied to it. Platforms catch them with pattern detection. The reported numbers, by platform.
- What is review gating, and is it allowed?FRAUDReview gating steers happy customers to public review sites and unhappy ones elsewhere. Google bans it; FTC staff call selective asking misleading.
- Can a business offer a discount or gift for a review?FRAUDFederal rules ban incentives tied to a positive or negative review. Google, Yelp, Thumbtack and BBB ban incentives outright. Amazon allows only Vine.
- How can you tell if a business's reviews have been manipulated?FRAUDNo single sign proves manipulation. Regulators and platforms name the patterns they look for: bursts, clusters, wrong details and one-review accounts.
- Are AI-generated reviews allowed, and how many are being removed?FRAUDThe FTC rule treats AI-generated fake reviews like any other fake. Yelp filtered nearly 500,000 suspected AI reviews in 2025; Tripadvisor removed 214,000.
LAW 5
- What does the FTC's rule on fake reviews actually prohibit?LAWThe FTC's review rule took effect October 21, 2024. It bans fake reviews, sentiment-based incentives, hidden insider reviews and suppression.
- Can a company's contract stop you from posting a negative review?LAWNo. The Consumer Review Fairness Act voids form-contract terms that bar reviews, penalize them or claim ownership of them. What it covers and omits.
- Can a business remove a bad review about itself?LAWOn third-party platforms a business can report a review but not delete it. Removal follows content rules, not whether the review is negative.
- Can a review site be sued over a review or a star rating?LAWUnder Section 230, a platform is generally not treated as the publisher of users' reviews. Two Ninth Circuit Yelp cases show how courts apply it.
- Which companies has the FTC pursued over fake or suppressed reviews?LAWFrom a $12.8 million judgment over paid Amazon reviews in 2019 to Fashion Nova, Rytr and Sitejabber: the FTC's review cases and what each one established.
RESEARCH 3
- Why are almost all online ratings above 4 stars?RESEARCHReview distributions are J-shaped: many fives, some ones, little between. Self-selection drives it, and it squeezes most averages into a narrow band.
- Do star ratings actually predict quality?RESEARCHRatings strongly move sales and bookings, but a study of 1,272 products found they track expert quality scores poorly. What that means for services.
- Does replying to reviews change a business's rating?RESEARCHA hotel study found replying was followed by a 0.12-star rise and 12% more reviews. Other work found replies draw longer, more negative reviews.