Explainers / LAW
Which companies has the FTC pursued over fake or suppressed reviews?
Between 2019 and early 2025 the FTC brought cases over purchased Amazon reviews, employee-written reviews at Sunday Riley, suppressed reviews at Fashion Nova, an AI review generator and a platform that collected ratings before delivery. Each tested a different practice, and together they map onto the sections of the 2024 rule.
The 2024 rule did not appear from nowhere. It is a codification of what the Commission had been alleging, one case at a time, for five years. Reading the cases in order shows the agency working outward from the plainest fraud to the subtler kinds.
| When | Matter | Practice alleged | Outcome announced |
|---|---|---|---|
| February 2019 | Cure Encapsulations | Paying a website to post Amazon reviews | $12.8 million judgment, suspended on payment of $50,000 |
| October 2019 | Sunday Riley | Managers and staff posting reviews from fake accounts | Conduct order; 3 to 2 vote |
| January 2022 | Fashion Nova | Withholding reviews under four stars | $4.2 million |
| January 2023 | HomeAdvisor | Misrepresenting leads sold to service providers | Up to $7.2 million in redress |
| September 2024 | Rytr | Selling a tool that generates reviews | Order barring review-generation services; 3 to 2 vote |
| November 2024 | Sitejabber | Presenting checkout ratings as product experience | Order; 5 to 0 vote |
2019: Cure Encapsulations, the first paid-review case
The FTC called this its first case challenging fake paid reviews on an independent retail website. Cure Encapsulations sold a garcinia cambogia weight-loss supplement on Amazon. The FTC alleged that its owner paid a website, amazonverifiedreviews.com, to create and post reviews, and told the operator: "Please make my product … stay a five star."11 Federal Trade Commission, FTC Brings First Case Challenging Fake Paid Reviews on an Independent Retail Website (February 2019)
One detail from the complaint is worth keeping. The owner reportedly said the product needed an average rating of 4.3 out of 5 to have sales. A seller's own belief about where the threshold sits is a useful reminder of how much rides on a few tenths of a star.
The court order imposed a judgment of $12.8 million, suspended upon payment of $50,000 and certain unpaid taxes. The headline figure and the amount actually due were very different numbers.
2019: Sunday Riley, insider reviews
Eight months later came the insider version. The FTC alleged that managers at Sunday Riley Modern Skincare, including the chief executive, wrote reviews of the company's products on Sephora.com using fake accounts from November 2015 to August 2017, and asked employees to do the same. A July 2016 email told staff to "create three accounts on Sephora.com, registered as . . . different identities". After Sephora removed some reviews, the company obtained a VPN to hide its location.22 Federal Trade Commission, Devumi, Owner and CEO Settle FTC Charges; Sunday Riley Settles Charges Over Fake Reviews (October 2019)
The proposed order prohibited misrepresenting the status of reviewers and required disclosure of material connections; the FTC's release describes no payment. The vote was 3 to 2, with Commissioner Chopra issuing a separate statement joined by Commissioner Slaughter. Five years later, announcing the rule, the Commission said that "case-by-case enforcement without civil penalty authority might not be enough to deter" such practices.33 Federal Trade Commission, Federal Trade Commission Announces Final Rule Banning Fake Reviews and Testimonials (August 2024)
2022: Fashion Nova, suppression
Fashion Nova's case involved no fake reviews at all. The FTC alleged that from late 2015 until November 2019 the retailer used a third-party review management interface to post four and five star reviews automatically and hold lower ratings for approval, and that it never approved "hundreds of thousands" of them. The company agreed to pay $4.2 million.44 Federal Trade Commission, Fashion Nova will Pay $4.2 Million as part of Settlement of FTC Allegations it Blocked Negative Reviews (January 2022)
This was the Commission's statement that curating real reviews can deceive as effectively as inventing them. Section 465.7(b) of the later rule is this case written as a regulation.55 Code of Federal Regulations, 16 CFR 465.7, Review suppression
2023: HomeAdvisor, a platform's own claims
HomeAdvisor's case was not about consumer reviews, and we include it because the company is one of the platforms this site covers and because it shows the FTC holding a home-services marketplace to account for its own statements. The complaint, filed in March 2022, alleged that since at least mid-2014 HomeAdvisor had misrepresented the quality of the leads it sold to service providers, the rate at which leads turned into jobs, and the cost of an optional software subscription. The January 2023 order required payment of up to $7.2 million in redress to affected providers.66 Federal Trade Commission, FTC Order Requires HomeAdvisor to Pay Up to $7.2 Million (January 2023)
The injured parties here were contractors, who paid an annual fee of $287.99 plus a charge per lead. For a homeowner, the relevance is indirect: it is a reminder that the businesses appearing in a marketplace's results are also its paying customers.
2024: Rytr, the generator
In September 2024, as part of a sweep the agency called a crackdown on deceptive AI claims and schemes, the FTC brought a complaint against Rytr, whose writing tool included a testimonial and review generator. The agency alleged the output contained specific details unrelated to the user's input and that some subscribers generated hundreds or tens of thousands of reviews.77 Federal Trade Commission, FTC Announces Crackdown on Deceptive AI Claims and Schemes (September 2024)
No fake review posted by Rytr was alleged. The theory was that supplying the means to produce false reviews at scale is itself deceptive and unfair. Two commissioners dissented.
2024: Sitejabber, timing
Sitejabber, a review platform operated by GGL Projects, collected ratings from customers at the point of sale, asking them to rate "your overall shopping experience so far" before they had received anything. The FTC alleged that these ratings were then presented as reflecting customers' experience with the product or service, inflating clients' averages and review counts, including in search results.88 Federal Trade Commission, FTC Order Against AI-Enabled Review Platform Sitejabber (November 2024)
The order bars misrepresenting that ratings reflect the views of customers who received the product. The vote was unanimous, and a later FTC notice records the order as finalized in January 2025.
This is the subtlest practice on the list. Each rating came from a real customer who really clicked five stars. The deception lay in when the question was asked.
What the sequence shows
Line the cases up against the rule and the correspondence is close.
- Purchased reviews (Cure Encapsulations) became section 465.2(b).
- Insider reviews (Sunday Riley) became section 465.5.
- Suppression (Fashion Nova) became section 465.7(b).
- Rytr and Sitejabber, both announced around the time the rule took effect, were brought under Section 5 and reach conduct by intermediaries that the rule covers only in part.
The other thing the sequence shows is the gap between allegation and money. Of the five review matters, the releases for three describe conduct orders without a payment, and one describes a judgment that was almost entirely suspended. Under the rule, courts can impose civil penalties for knowing violations, with a per-violation maximum the FTC set at $53,088 in January 2025.99 Federal Trade Commission, FTC Publishes Inflation-Adjusted Civil Penalty Amounts for 2025
As of this writing we have not reviewed any court judgment imposing civil penalties under Part 465 itself, so we cannot yet say how courts are counting violations.
Questions readers ask
What was the first FTC case about paid fake reviews?
The Cure Encapsulations case, announced February 26, 2019, which the FTC described as its first challenging fake paid reviews on an independent retail website.11 Federal Trade Commission, FTC Brings First Case Challenging Fake Paid Reviews on an Independent Retail Website (February 2019)
Has the FTC fined a company for hiding negative reviews?
Fashion Nova agreed to pay $4.2 million in 2022 to settle allegations that it blocked reviews below four stars from its website.44 Federal Trade Commission, Fashion Nova will Pay $4.2 Million as part of Settlement of FTC Allegations it Blocked Negative Reviews (January 2022)
Do these cases apply to small local businesses?
The legal standards do. The rule's definition of a business includes an individual who sells products or services.1010 Code of Federal Regulations, 16 CFR 465.1, Definitions
Method Each entry is drawn from the FTC's own press release for the matter. Allegations in settled cases were not tested at trial, and we describe them as allegations. See how we source and check.
Sources
Every source below was opened and read for this page. Links go to the publisher's own copy.
- Federal Trade Commission. FTC Brings First Case Challenging Fake Paid Reviews on an Independent Retail Website (February 2019)
- Federal Trade Commission. Devumi, Owner and CEO Settle FTC Charges; Sunday Riley Settles Charges Over Fake Reviews (October 2019)
- Federal Trade Commission. Federal Trade Commission Announces Final Rule Banning Fake Reviews and Testimonials (August 2024)
- Federal Trade Commission. Fashion Nova will Pay $4.2 Million as part of Settlement of FTC Allegations it Blocked Negative Reviews (January 2022)
- Code of Federal Regulations. 16 CFR 465.7, Review suppression
- Federal Trade Commission. FTC Order Requires HomeAdvisor to Pay Up to $7.2 Million (January 2023)
- Federal Trade Commission. FTC Announces Crackdown on Deceptive AI Claims and Schemes (September 2024)
- Federal Trade Commission. FTC Order Against AI-Enabled Review Platform Sitejabber (November 2024)
- Federal Trade Commission. FTC Publishes Inflation-Adjusted Civil Penalty Amounts for 2025
- Code of Federal Regulations. 16 CFR 465.1, Definitions