Explainers / FRAUD
What is review gating, and is it allowed?
Review gating is asking customers how they feel first, then sending only the satisfied ones to a public review site. Google's policy prohibits it. FTC staff say asking only customers you expect to be happy is misleading, although the 2024 rule does not expressly ban it.
The mechanics are simple. After a job, the customer gets a text: "How did we do?" with a row of faces or stars. Tap four or five and the next screen is a link to the Google review form. Tap one, two or three and the next screen is a private feedback box that goes to the owner's inbox. Every review that reaches Google is real. The set of reviews is rigged.
Gating is the polite cousin of fake reviews. It requires no lying by anyone who writes a word, which is what makes it attractive.
What the platforms say
Google. The Maps content policy states that merchants may not "discourage or prohibit negative reviews, or selectively solicit positive reviews from customers".11 Google Maps Help, Prohibited and restricted content, Maps user-contributed content policy Asking is fine. Google's own help page suggests reminding customers and offers a link or QR code.22 Google Business Profile Help, Tips to get more reviews The violation is in the selection.
Yelp. Yelp avoids the question by discouraging all asking. Its guidance says: "Don't ask for reviews after requesting customer feedback in other places like surveys or contact forms", and notes that "many businesses only ask happy customers for reviews, which leads to biased ratings".33 Yelp Support Center, Don't Ask for Reviews
Trustpilot. Businesses that send invitations are asked "to invite all their customers equally and identically (or using a neutral system), and with neutral language".44 Trustpilot Help Center, Why are some reviews marked "Verified"?
What the FTC says
The law here has layers, and it is worth being exact about them.
The Consumer Reviews and Testimonials Rule, effective October 21, 2024, has a section on review suppression. It covers threats and intimidation aimed at reviewers, and it covers a business misrepresenting that the reviews shown on its own site represent most or all reviews submitted when reviews are being suppressed based on rating or sentiment.55 Code of Federal Regulations, 16 CFR 465.7, Review suppression It does not, in its text, reach a business that chooses whom to ask for a review on a third-party site.
FTC staff addressed that gap directly. In the rule's question-and-answer document, staff say that asking only happy customers for reviews is not expressly banned by the rule but may violate the FTC Act.66 Federal Trade Commission, Consumer Reviews and Testimonials Rule: Questions and Answers The older Endorsement Guides guidance is firmer. Asked whether a company could skip sending review links to customers in areas where it knew service was poor, staff answered: "No. Only asking for reviews from customers who you think are more likely to be happy with your product would be misleading."77 Federal Trade Commission, FTC's Endorsement Guides: What People Are Asking
The FTC's guide for platforms puts it in one line: "Don't ask for reviews only from people you think will leave positive ones."88 Federal Trade Commission, Featuring Online Customer Reviews: A Guide for Platforms Its companion guide for marketers makes the same point about cherry-picking.99 Federal Trade Commission, Soliciting and Paying for Online Reviews: A Guide for Marketers
So the position is this. Gating is not a per-violation civil penalty offense under the 2024 rule as written. It is conduct that FTC staff consider deceptive under Section 5 of the FTC Act, and it violates Google's content policy.
The Fashion Nova case shows the on-site version
When a company gates reviews on its own website, the rule and prior case law apply squarely. The FTC alleged that Fashion Nova used a third-party review management interface to post four and five star reviews automatically while holding lower-rated reviews for approval that never came. Hundreds of thousands of reviews were withheld between late 2015 and November 2019. The company agreed to pay $4.2 million.1010 Federal Trade Commission, Fashion Nova will Pay $4.2 Million as part of Settlement of FTC Allegations it Blocked Negative Reviews (January 2022)
The allegation was not that any posted review was fake. It was that the site represented its reviews as reflecting all buyers who submitted one.
Softer forms of the same thing
Gating shades into practices that feel innocent to the business doing them.
- Timing. Asking at the moment of delivery, before anything can go wrong, selects for satisfaction. The FTC's Sitejabber case involved ratings collected at checkout, before customers had received what they bought, and then presented as reviews of the experience.1111 Federal Trade Commission, FTC Order Against AI-Enabled Review Platform Sitejabber (November 2024)
- Asking in person. Staff ask the customers they have just had a pleasant chat with. Google's policy says merchants should not "require or pressure users to leave ratings or write reviews while on the premises".11 Google Maps Help, Prohibited and restricted content, Maps user-contributed content policy
- Delay. Holding negative reviews for "moderation" while positives post instantly. FTC staff note that "delaying the posting only of negative reviews, even just by a few days, could create a biased picture".77 Federal Trade Commission, FTC's Endorsement Guides: What People Are Asking
- Ordering. Listing all five-star reviews first. Staff say a consumer "could get a misleading picture of what users think".77 Federal Trade Commission, FTC's Endorsement Guides: What People Are Asking
- Recovery. Contacting unhappy reviewers to fix the problem is welcome. Staff add that "asking them to change or delete their initial negative reviews could mislead readers".77 Federal Trade Commission, FTC's Endorsement Guides: What People Are Asking
Why gating is hard to see from outside
A gated profile contains only real reviews from real customers. Text analysis will find nothing. What gating changes is the distribution: too many fives, too few threes and fours, and a thin scatter of ones from the customers angry enough to find the review page on their own.
That shape, a tall five-star bar, almost nothing in the middle and a small one-star bar, is also the shape of honest self-selected reviews, so the histogram alone proves nothing. Better clues:
- Compare platforms. A gating funnel points customers at one review site at a time. If a business has 600 Google reviews at 4.9 and its Yelp or BBB profile reads very differently, ask why.
- Read the one-star reviews for mentions of the process. Look for any reviewer who describes being surveyed first and never receiving a public link.
- Look at the rate. A sudden jump from two reviews a month to forty marks the day a review-request tool was switched on. That is not proof of gating, but it tells you the profile is now managed.
Is asking everyone fine?
Yes, by every policy cited here except Yelp's. The FTC's guidance to platforms and marketers asks for neutrality: ask people who used the product, do not cherry-pick, do not condition rewards on sentiment.99 Federal Trade Commission, Soliciting and Paying for Online Reviews: A Guide for Marketers A business that sends the same request to every customer, with a direct link and no survey in front of it, is doing what Google and the FTC describe as acceptable.
Questions readers ask
Is review gating illegal in the United States?
FTC staff say asking only customers expected to be positive is misleading and may violate the FTC Act. The 2024 rule on reviews does not expressly ban selective solicitation on third-party sites, but it does ban misrepresenting suppressed on-site reviews as complete.66 Federal Trade Commission, Consumer Reviews and Testimonials Rule: Questions and Answers
Will Google remove reviews collected through gating?
Google's policy says rating manipulation is not allowed and such content will be removed, and it lists selective solicitation among prohibited merchant practices.11 Google Maps Help, Prohibited and restricted content, Maps user-contributed content policy How often Google detects gating, the platform does not disclose.
Method Policy language is quoted from Google, Yelp and Trustpilot pages. The legal position is taken from FTC staff guidance, which the FTC notes is not a safe harbor. See how we source and check.
Sources
Every source below was opened and read for this page. Links go to the publisher's own copy.
- Google Maps Help. Prohibited and restricted content, Maps user-contributed content policy
- Google Business Profile Help. Tips to get more reviews
- Yelp Support Center. Don't Ask for Reviews
- Trustpilot Help Center. Why are some reviews marked "Verified"?
- Code of Federal Regulations. 16 CFR 465.7, Review suppression
- Federal Trade Commission. Consumer Reviews and Testimonials Rule: Questions and Answers
- Federal Trade Commission. FTC's Endorsement Guides: What People Are Asking
- Federal Trade Commission. Featuring Online Customer Reviews: A Guide for Platforms
- Federal Trade Commission. Soliciting and Paying for Online Reviews: A Guide for Marketers
- Federal Trade Commission. Fashion Nova will Pay $4.2 Million as part of Settlement of FTC Allegations it Blocked Negative Reviews (January 2022)
- Federal Trade Commission. FTC Order Against AI-Enabled Review Platform Sitejabber (November 2024)