RATINGS/DECODED

Explainers / MECHANICS

BBB letter grade vs customer reviews: why an A+ can sit beside one star

The BBB publishes two unrelated numbers. The letter grade, A+ to F, is scored from complaint handling, time in business and similar elements. The star average comes from customer reviews. The BBB states that reviews are not used in the letter grade.

A national company with thousands of furious one-star reviews on its BBB profile can hold an A+. People take this as proof the grade is for sale. The better explanation is duller: the grade was never designed to measure whether customers are happy.

What goes into the letter grade

The BBB scores businesses on a 100-point scale. Its published table lists what can add or subtract points:11 Better Business Bureau, Overview of BBB Ratings

Rating elementPoints, best to worst
Unanswered complaints40 to 0
Unresolved complaints30 to 0
Complaint volume, weighted by age15 to 0
Time in business10 to 0
Complaint resolution delayed5 to 0
Transparent business practices0 to minus 5
Failure to address a complaint pattern0 to minus 31
Type of business0 to minus 41
Failure to honor mediation or arbitration0 to minus 41
Competency licensing0 to minus 41
Advertising review, per incident0 to minus 41
BBB trademark infringement0 to minus 41

Add the positive maximums: 40 + 30 + 15 + 10 + 5 = 100. Seventy of those hundred points turn on whether the business answers complaints and resolves them. Another 15 depend on complaint volume, weighted by the age of the complaints, and 10 on how long the business has operated.

The grade bands are equally mechanical:

GradeScore
A+97 to 100
A94 to 96.99
A minus90 to 93.99
B+, B, B minus87 to 89.99, 84 to 86.99, 80 to 83.99
C+, C, C minus77 to 79.99, 74 to 76.99, 70 to 73.99
D+, D, D minus67 to 69.99, 64 to 66.99, 60 to 63.99
F0 to 59.99

A business rated NR has no grade; the BBB says this means there is not enough information or the file is under review, and that NR is not negative.11 Better Business Bureau, Overview of BBB Ratings

What this design rewards

Responding. A company that receives 500 complaints a year, answers every one within the deadline and offers a resolution the BBB records as adequate can keep nearly all 70 complaint-handling points. Its customers may still be miserable. The grade is measuring whether the company engages with the dispute process, which is what the BBB runs.

It follows that the letter grade is most informative at the bottom. Given the weights, an F most plausibly means complaints went unanswered or a heavy deduction applied, and either is a concrete fact about a business. An A+ tells you less: complaints, if any, got a reply.

Where customer reviews fit

BBB customer reviews are 1 to 5 star reviews of marketplace experiences. They are processed with more friction than on most sites:22 Better Business Bureau, BBB Customer Reviews33 Better Business Bureau, Frequently Asked Questions about BBB customer reviews

  • The reviewer's email address or phone number is validated.
  • Anonymous reviews are not accepted, and the reviewer's name is shared with the business.
  • The review is sent to the business before it is published, and the business can respond.
  • Incentivized reviews are refused, including those tied to discounts or gifts.
  • A consumer may file a review or a complaint about an issue, but not both.

And then the key sentence: "Unlike complaints, customer reviews are not considered as part of a business's BBB Rating."33 Better Business Bureau, Frequently Asked Questions about BBB customer reviews

So the two numbers share a web page and nothing else. Complaints feed the grade. Reviews feed the stars.

Why BBB review averages run low

Look up almost any large consumer company and the BBB star average is strikingly poor next to its Google score. We cannot cite a study that measures this, so treat the following as reasoning, not a finding. People generally arrive at bbb.org when something has gone wrong. The site's own process page presents a fork: file a complaint to get help, or leave a review to share an opinion.44 Better Business Bureau, Process of Complaints and Reviews A visitor in that frame of mind who picks the review path is unlikely to be writing about a pleasant Tuesday. The BBB's reviewer pool is drawn from the unhappy end of the customer base in a way that Google's is not.

Accreditation is a third thing

Accredited businesses pay a fee and commit to the BBB's eight standards, one of which requires them to "maintain at least a B rating".55 Better Business Bureau, BBB Accreditation Standards Accreditation is not listed among the rating elements on the BBB's overview page. A non-accredited business can hold an A+, and the points table above applies to accredited and non-accredited businesses alike.

Reading a BBB profile in practice

  1. Open the complaints tab, not just the grade. Count complaints in the past 12 months and read how the business answered.
  2. Look for repetition yourself. "Failure to address a complaint pattern" can cost up to 31 points, so scan the complaints for the same issue coming up again and again.
  3. Use the star average as a list of worst cases. It over-samples bad experiences, which makes it a poor estimate of the typical one and a good catalog of how things go wrong.
  4. Compare the complaint count with the size of the company. Forty complaints about a utility with millions of customers and forty about a three-truck HVAC firm are different facts. The BBB's table says complaint volume is weighted by complaint age; the page we read does not spell out how business size enters.

Questions readers ask

Can a business pay the BBB for a better grade?

The published rating elements do not include accreditation or payment.11 Better Business Bureau, Overview of BBB Ratings Businesses do pay a fee for accreditation, which is a separate status with its own standards.55 Better Business Bureau, BBB Accreditation Standards

Does a bad review lower a company's BBB grade?

No. Only complaints, which go through the BBB's dispute process, affect the grade. Reviews produce the star average and nothing else.33 Better Business Bureau, Frequently Asked Questions about BBB customer reviews

What does it mean if a company has an F?

On the published scale, a score below 60. Given the weights, that most often reflects unanswered or unresolved complaints, or a large deduction such as an advertising or licensing issue.11 Better Business Bureau, Overview of BBB Ratings

Method Point values and grade bands are copied from the BBB's "Overview of BBB Ratings" page; review rules come from its customer review pages and FAQ. See how we source and check.

Sources

Every source below was opened and read for this page. Links go to the publisher's own copy.

  1. Better Business Bureau. Overview of BBB Ratings
  2. Better Business Bureau. BBB Customer Reviews
  3. Better Business Bureau. Frequently Asked Questions about BBB customer reviews
  4. Better Business Bureau. Process of Complaints and Reviews
  5. Better Business Bureau. BBB Accreditation Standards