Explainers / LAW
Can a review site be sued over a review or a star rating?
Generally no. Section 230 of the Communications Decency Act says a platform shall not be treated as the publisher or speaker of information provided by someone else. The Ninth Circuit has applied that to Yelp reviews and to the aggregate star rating itself. The person who wrote the review can still be liable.
Two sentences in one federal statute explain why review platforms exist in their current form.
The first: "No provider or user of an interactive computer service shall be treated as the publisher or speaker of any information provided by another information content provider."11 United States Code, 47 U.S.C. 230, Protection for private blocking and screening of offensive material
The second protects moderation. No provider shall be held liable for "any action voluntarily taken in good faith to restrict access to or availability of material" that it considers obscene, harassing "or otherwise objectionable".
Read together, a platform is not liable for leaving a user's review up, and not liable for taking one down in good faith. Both halves matter to review sites, which do both things millions of times a year.
The key definition
Immunity depends on who created the content. The statute defines an "information content provider" as any person or entity "responsible, in whole or in part, for the creation or development of information".11 United States Code, 47 U.S.C. 230, Protection for private blocking and screening of offensive material If the platform itself wrote or materially developed the statement, it is a content provider for that statement and the shield does not apply.
So the litigated question is nearly always the same: did the platform merely host this, or did it help make it?
Kimzey v. Yelp: is the star rating Yelp's own speech?
Douglas Kimzey owned a locksmith business in the greater Seattle area. In 2011 a Yelp user identified as Sarah K posted a one-star review. Kimzey sued Yelp, and tried a clever route around Section 230. He alleged that Yelp "designed and created its signature star-rating system" and so was the author of the one-star rating, and that Yelp republished the review as an advertisement on Google.22 U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit, Kimzey v. Yelp! Inc., No. 14-35487 (filed September 12, 2016)
In September 2016 the Ninth Circuit affirmed dismissal. Judge McKeown's opinion called these characterizations superficially appealing but said they "extend the concept of an 'information content provider' too far and would render the CDA's immunity provisions meaningless". On the rating specifically, the court wrote that the star-rating system "is best characterized as the kind of 'neutral tool[]' operating on 'voluntary inputs'" that does not amount to content creation.22 U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit, Kimzey v. Yelp! Inc., No. 14-35487 (filed September 12, 2016)
The practical meaning: reducing user reviews to a single aggregate number is, in the Ninth Circuit, still user-generated data. A business cannot make the platform the author of its 2.5 stars by pointing out that the platform built the widget.
Levitt v. Yelp: is selling ads beside reviews extortion?
Section 230 was not the deciding issue in Levitt, but the case belongs here because it tests the other common theory against review sites. Several small business owners alleged that Yelp manipulated reviews, and in some instances wrote negative ones, to pressure them into buying advertising.
In September 2014 the Ninth Circuit affirmed dismissal of the extortion-based claims. The panel held that "unless a person has a pre-existing right to be free of the threatened economic harm, threatening economic harm to induce a person to pay for a legitimate service is not extortion".33 U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit, Levitt v. Yelp! Inc., No. 11-17676 (filed September 2, 2014) Businesses have no legal right to positive reviews on someone else's platform, so withholding a benefit of that kind, even as a bargaining tool, did not meet the definition.
On the allegation that Yelp authored negative reviews, the court found the complaint did not sufficiently allege it. That is a ruling about what was pleaded, not a finding of fact about Yelp's conduct. Yelp's published position is that its software treats advertisers and non-advertisers alike and cannot be overridden by employees.44 Yelp Support Center, Why would a review not be recommended?
What Section 230 does not cover
The reviewer. The author of a review is the information content provider and is fully exposed to a defamation claim if the review contains false statements of fact. Section 230 moves liability; it does not erase it.
Content the platform itself creates. A platform's own editorial statements, its own written summaries and anything it fabricates are its speech. The Kimzey court took care to note there were no facts plausibly suggesting Yelp fabricated the content.
The platform's own promises and conduct. Section 230 concerns treatment as publisher of another's content. It is not a general immunity from consumer protection law. The FTC's case against HomeAdvisor concerned the company's own representations to service providers about its leads, not anything users posted, and ended with an order to pay up to $7.2 million.55 Federal Trade Commission, FTC Order Requires HomeAdvisor to Pay Up to $7.2 Million (January 2023)
Businesses that buy or write fake reviews. The FTC's 2024 rule imposes liability on the business that creates or purchases the fake. The rule treats mere "consumer review hosting" as outside its prohibitions, which runs parallel to Section 230's logic.66 Code of Federal Regulations, 16 CFR 465.1, Definitions
Why this shapes what you see
Because platforms are not liable for hosting, they do not have to verify a review before publishing it, and they do not have to remove one because a business complains or threatens. Because they are protected when moderating in good faith, they can build aggressive filters. Yelp's two-pile system and Google's pre-publication screening both sit comfortably inside that structure.
It also explains a pattern that frustrates business owners. A demand letter to the platform typically goes nowhere, since the platform has no liability to settle. The legal route, where one exists, runs through the person who wrote the review, and platforms resist identifying anonymous users. Yelp says that in 2025 it avoided producing personal information for 99% of the 4,267 user accounts that were the subject of legal demands.77 Yelp Trust and Safety, 2025 Trust and Safety Report
For readers, the consequence is a trade. Open hosting means more reviews, including critical ones that a liability-averse publisher would spike. It also means nobody with legal responsibility has vouched for any particular review. The verification, such as it is, comes from the platform's commercial interest in being believed.
Limits of this summary
Both cases are from one federal appeals court, and other courts have their own Section 230 case law. We have described what these two opinions hold and nothing more.
Questions readers ask
Can I sue Google or Yelp over a false review?
Under Section 230 a platform is generally not treated as the publisher of a user's review, and courts have dismissed such claims.22 U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit, Kimzey v. Yelp! Inc., No. 14-35487 (filed September 12, 2016) A claim against the person who wrote a false statement of fact is a different matter.
Does moderating reviews make a platform legally responsible for them?
No. The statute separately protects good-faith decisions to restrict access to objectionable material.11 United States Code, 47 U.S.C. 230, Protection for private blocking and screening of offensive material
Did a court find that Yelp manipulates reviews for advertisers?
No. In Levitt the Ninth Circuit affirmed dismissal because the allegations, even if true, did not amount to extortion, and it found the claim that Yelp wrote negative reviews insufficiently pleaded.33 U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit, Levitt v. Yelp! Inc., No. 11-17676 (filed September 2, 2014)
Method Quotations are from the statute and from the two Ninth Circuit opinions as published by the court. We summarize holdings and do not predict outcomes in other circuits. Not legal advice. See how we source and check.
Sources
Every source below was opened and read for this page. Links go to the publisher's own copy.
- United States Code. 47 U.S.C. 230, Protection for private blocking and screening of offensive material
- U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit. Kimzey v. Yelp! Inc., No. 14-35487 (filed September 12, 2016)
- U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit. Levitt v. Yelp! Inc., No. 11-17676 (filed September 2, 2014)
- Yelp Support Center. Why would a review not be recommended?
- Federal Trade Commission. FTC Order Requires HomeAdvisor to Pay Up to $7.2 Million (January 2023)
- Code of Federal Regulations. 16 CFR 465.1, Definitions
- Yelp Trust and Safety. 2025 Trust and Safety Report