Explainers / RESEARCH
Does replying to reviews change a business's rating?
The evidence says yes, modestly. A study of hotels estimated a 0.12-star increase in ratings and a 12% increase in review volume after managers began responding. Other studies found that responses also invite more, and more detailed, negative reviews. Replies change who writes next and what they write.
The reply box under a review looks like a courtesy feature. Research on hotels suggests it is a lever, with effects on the rating that are measurable and not entirely in one direction.
Study one: replies raise ratings a little
Proserpio and Zervas compared hotels across review platforms, using differences in how often hotels responded on each platform and in how likely consumers were to see those responses. Their findings:11 Proserpio and Zervas, Marketing Science 36(5), 2017, Online Reputation Management: Estimating the Impact of Management Responses on Consumer Reviews
- Hotels tend to start responding after a negative shock to their ratings.
- Hotels respond to positive, negative and neutral reviews at roughly the same rate.
- Responding hotels saw "a 0.12-star increase in ratings and a 12% increase in review volume".
- After hotels began responding, they received "fewer but longer negative reviews".
The authors' explanation for the last point is about deterrence. Unhappy guests "become less likely to leave short indefensible reviews when hotels are likely to scrutinize them". A drive-by one-star with no detail is less tempting when the manager will answer it publicly. The guests who still complain write more, and more carefully.
They describe the result as a trade-off: "fewer negative ratings at the cost of longer and more detailed negative feedback".
Study two: replies invite more criticism
Chevalier, Dover and Mayzlin reached a conclusion that looks contradictory at first. They argue that people write reviews partly to influence the business, and that a manager's reply is "a credible signal that the service provider is listening". Using comparisons of the same hotel before and after it began responding, and across sites that did and did not allow responses, they found that "reviewing activity and particularly negative reviewing is indeed stimulated by managerial response".22 Chevalier, Dover and Mayzlin, Marketing Science 37(5), 2018, Channels of Impact: User Reviews When Quality Is Dynamic and Managers Respond
They also observed that managers respond more, and in more detail, to negative reviews, which heightens the effect.
The two studies agree on more than they differ. Both find that replying increases review volume. Both find that replying changes the character of negative reviews. They differ on the net direction for negative volume, which may reflect different data, platforms and periods. A reader should take from the pair that replies reliably generate engagement and that the effect on the average is small either way.
Study three: it depends what you reply to
Wang and Chaudhry separated replies to negative reviews from replies to positive ones and looked at what later reviewers did. Replies to negative reviews "can significantly influence subsequent opinion in a positive way if those responses are observable at the time of reviewing". Replies to positive reviews had a negative effect on subsequent ratings.33 Wang and Chaudhry, Journal of Marketing Research 55(2), 2018, When and How Managers' Responses to Online Reviews Affect Subsequent Reviews
Tailoring sharpened both effects. A specific reply to a complaint helped more than a generic one. A specific reply to praise hurt more, apparently because highlighting the compliments made the manager's motive look promotional.
That finding lines up with Google's advice to businesses, which says: "Instead of sending the same 'thank you' to everyone, focus on reviews where you can share a helpful update or answer a question", and "Be conversational, not promotional".44 Google Business Profile Help, Tips to get more reviews
What platforms do with replies
Replies do not enter the score on any platform that has said anything about it. Tripadvisor is explicit that management responses are not factored into its Popularity Ranking.55 Tripadvisor Insights, Everything you need to know about the Tripadvisor Popularity Ranking Google, Angi and Nextdoor encourage replies as good practice without describing any direct effect on rating or rank.66 Angi Help Center, Reviews: Frequently Asked Questions (for pros)77 Nextdoor for Business, Small business guide to getting Nextdoor recommendations
Scale is considerable. Tripadvisor reports that business owners responded to over 11 million reviews in 2024, against 31.1 million reviews submitted.88 Tripadvisor, 2025 Transparency Report press release (March 2025)
Some platforms limit the exchange. On Thumbtack a pro's response "cannot be edited or changed once submitted", and if a customer updates a verified review the pro may respond once more.99 Thumbtack Help, Content and Review Policy BBB permits only the reviewer and the business to comment.1010 Better Business Bureau, BBB Customer Reviews
Reading replies as a customer
For someone evaluating a business, the replies are primary evidence in a way the reviews are not. A review is a stranger's account. A reply is the business itself, in writing, under mild stress.
Things worth noticing:
Does it engage with the specific complaint? "We're sorry you feel that way, please call our office" tells you nothing. "The technician arrived at 3:40 for a 1 to 3 window; we credited the service fee the next day" tells you the business tracks its jobs and corrects errors.
Does it attack the reviewer? Replies that disclose a customer's private details or question their honesty are a preview of how a dispute with you would go. There is also a legal edge: the FTC rule bars a public false accusation made knowingly or recklessly in response to a review in an attempt to get it removed.1111 Code of Federal Regulations, 16 CFR 465.7, Review suppression
Is every reply the same sentence? Copy-pasted replies show a process without attention.
Does it reply only to praise? By the Wang and Chaudhry result, that is the pattern that does a business least good, and it suggests the replies are there as marketing.
Do the replies start abruptly? Proserpio and Zervas found hotels tend to begin responding after a ratings shock. Scroll back to where the replies begin and read what was happening.
A caution on transferring hotel findings
All three studies used hotel data. Hotels have high review volume, many one-time customers and professional managers. A two-person landscaping firm with 40 reviews differs on every count. The mechanisms, scrutiny deterring careless complaints and a visible listener encouraging detailed ones, are plausible for any business. The sizes of the effects should not be carried over. A 0.12-star estimate from thousands of hotels says nothing precise about what will happen to one plumber.
Questions readers ask
Do replies to reviews improve search ranking?
Tripadvisor says management responses are not a ranking factor.55 Tripadvisor Insights, Everything you need to know about the Tripadvisor Popularity Ranking We found no statement in Google's help pages that replies affect local ranking, and we will not assert one.
Should a business reply to every review?
The research suggests priority goes to negative reviews, with specific answers, and that effusive tailored replies to positive reviews can backfire.33 Wang and Chaudhry, Journal of Marketing Research 55(2), 2018, When and How Managers' Responses to Online Reviews Affect Subsequent Reviews
Can a business edit its reply later?
It varies. On Thumbtack a response cannot be edited once submitted.99 Thumbtack Help, Content and Review Policy
Method Three peer-reviewed studies of hotel reviews, summarized from their published abstracts, alongside what platforms say about replies. All three concern hotels; we flag where we extend the reasoning to other businesses. See how we source and check.
Sources
Every source below was opened and read for this page. Links go to the publisher's own copy.
- Proserpio and Zervas, Marketing Science 36(5), 2017. Online Reputation Management: Estimating the Impact of Management Responses on Consumer Reviews
- Chevalier, Dover and Mayzlin, Marketing Science 37(5), 2018. Channels of Impact: User Reviews When Quality Is Dynamic and Managers Respond
- Wang and Chaudhry, Journal of Marketing Research 55(2), 2018. When and How Managers' Responses to Online Reviews Affect Subsequent Reviews
- Google Business Profile Help. Tips to get more reviews
- Tripadvisor Insights. Everything you need to know about the Tripadvisor Popularity Ranking
- Angi Help Center. Reviews: Frequently Asked Questions (for pros)
- Nextdoor for Business. Small business guide to getting Nextdoor recommendations
- Tripadvisor. 2025 Transparency Report press release (March 2025)
- Thumbtack Help. Content and Review Policy
- Better Business Bureau. BBB Customer Reviews
- Code of Federal Regulations. 16 CFR 465.7, Review suppression