RATINGS/DECODED

Platforms / THUMBTACK

How Thumbtack reviews, ratings and search rank work

Thumbtack accepts reviews from anyone who had an actual or attempted interaction with a pro and marks those from on-platform hires with "Hired on Thumbtack". It bans incentivized reviews. A pro's search rank reflects review rating and count together with responsiveness and the price the pro pays per lead.

Scale
1 to 5 stars
Formula
Not published
Who can review
Consumers with an actual or attempted interaction with the pro
Filtering
Policy-based removal; time windows; disputes within 30 days
Asking for reviews
Allowed; incentives prohibited

Thumbtack connects customers with local service pros, who pay for leads. Its review rules are more precisely written than most, particularly on who counts as having had an experience.

Who can review, and when

The policy prohibits "reviews that are not based on an actual or attempted interaction between the pro and the consumer", and then defines the edge cases by example.11 Thumbtack Help, Content and Review Policy

  • A consumer who reaches out and "does not hear back" has attempted to interact, and may review.
  • A consumer who received a quote has interacted, and may review.

This is broader than platforms that require a completed job. A pro can be reviewed for ignoring an inquiry or for the manner of a quote. For a reader, that means some low reviews describe responsiveness and price, not workmanship. Read which is which.

Timing is bounded. Reviews must be posted "within six months after the last interaction" or "within one year of the last day the pro worked on the project".

Verified and unverified

"Verified reviews are from customers who have connected with a pro on Thumbtack, and have posted a review on that project." The marker is "Hired on Thumbtack".22 Thumbtack, How we're committed to your safety Pros can also gather reviews from customers found elsewhere, and those appear without the badge.

Verified reviews have one extra property: the consumer "can make one update" to each, and the pro can respond once to the update.11 Thumbtack Help, Content and Review Policy

What the number means

What the number means on Thumbtack
You seeWhat it isLimits
Star ratingSummary of customer reviews, 1 to 5Formula not published; may include unverified reviews
Hired on ThumbtackReview from a customer who connected with the pro on the platformConfirms the connection, not the quality of work
Top Pro"Highly rated across several reviews from Thumbtack customers"Exact thresholds not given on the page we read
Licensed proLicense number checked against a public databaseCheck the state board for current status and discipline
Position in resultsRank built from reviews, responsiveness, engagement and lead pricesPartly paid
"Three best matches"Pros with a 4.5+ rating, at least three reviews and replies within four hours on averageThree reviews is a small sample

Prohibited reviews

Beyond the interaction rule, the policy bars reviews that are political or social commentary, discriminatory, late, or incentivized, defined as "provided in exchange for an incentive, such as a discount, an entry into a sweepstake, a rebate, or cash".11 Thumbtack Help, Content and Review Policy

The general content rules, which apply to reviews as well, prohibit fraudulent or deceptive content, including "digitally altered or AI-generated media" used to fake a portfolio or fabricate evidence.

Editing, responses and disputes

"Thumbtack doesn't edit or change reviews." A pro may respond, and the response "cannot be edited or changed once submitted".

If a dispute arises between a consumer and a pro, relevant reviews "may be removed or hidden at Thumbtack's discretion until a resolution is reached". To dispute a review, the user "must contact Thumbtack within 30 days of the review being posted".11 Thumbtack Help, Content and Review Policy

That hide-during-dispute rule is worth knowing. A profile may be temporarily missing its most contentious review while the two sides argue.

How rank is set

Thumbtack tells pros what moves them up.33 Thumbtack Help, How to improve my rank in search results

  • Responsiveness. Accepting and answering leads quickly.
  • Reviews. "Your review rating and the number of reviews on your profile are factored into your ranking."
  • Profile engagement. Pros rank better "as customers engage with your profile".
  • Lead prices. "Setting competitive prices helps you show up higher in search results." These are the prices the pro pays Thumbtack per lead.

It adds that rank is "influenced by other pros in your market".

The featured "three best matches" section has published entry criteria: at least a 4.5-star rating, at least three reviews, and an average response time to new customers of four hours or less.

Put plainly, ratings are one of four inputs to position, and one of the other three is money. The first few results are a blend of well-reviewed, quick to reply and willing to pay.

Screening

Thumbtack says all new account owners "must undergo a criminal background check through a nationally accredited third-party provider", repeated annually. Account owners are responsible for ensuring that their employees and contractors follow the terms and the law, "including local licensing requirements".22 Thumbtack, How we're committed to your safety

The same page describes a Money-Back Guarantee of up to $2,500 where a job is not done or not done as agreed, with notice required within 45 days, and a Property Damage Guarantee of up to $100,000, with notice within 14 days. Those are Thumbtack's stated terms as of November 2026; read the current conditions before relying on them.

What Thumbtack does not disclose

  • How the star rating is computed, and whether verified reviews weigh more.
  • The numerical criteria for Top Pro on its safety page.
  • The relative weight of lead price against reviews in ranking.

Questions readers ask

Can someone who never hired a pro leave a Thumbtack review?

Yes, if there was an actual or attempted interaction, such as receiving a quote or contacting the pro without a reply.11 Thumbtack Help, Content and Review Policy

What does "Hired on Thumbtack" mean on a review?

It marks a verified review from a customer who connected with the pro on Thumbtack and reviewed that project.22 Thumbtack, How we're committed to your safety

Do pros pay to rank higher on Thumbtack?

Thumbtack says competitive lead prices help a pro show up higher, alongside responsiveness, reviews and profile engagement.33 Thumbtack Help, How to improve my rank in search results

Method Built from Thumbtack's Content and Review Policy, its safety page and its help article on search rank. The rating formula itself is not described on those pages. See how we source and check.

Sources

Every source below was opened and read for this page. Links go to the publisher's own copy.

  1. Thumbtack Help. Content and Review Policy
  2. Thumbtack. How we're committed to your safety
  3. Thumbtack Help. How to improve my rank in search results