RATINGS/DECODED

Platforms / HOMEADVISOR

How HomeAdvisor ratings work, and what can be verified today

We could not open a current HomeAdvisor page that explains its ratings. In November 2026 the address homeadvisor.com/screening redirected to Angi's FAQ, and the FTC describes HomeAdvisor as affiliated with Angi. The best-documented fact about the platform is a 2023 FTC order over how it marketed leads to contractors.

Scale
Not confirmed from a current HomeAdvisor page
Formula
Not published on any HomeAdvisor page we could open
Who can review
Not confirmed; see Angi's rules, to which HomeAdvisor's screening URL forwards
Filtering
Not confirmed
Asking for reviews
Not confirmed

This is the shortest platform page on the site, on purpose. Our rule is to describe a rating system from the platform's own published policy. For HomeAdvisor, we could not open one.

What we could confirm

The affiliation. The Federal Trade Commission's January 2023 release describes HomeAdvisor, Inc. as a Denver-based company "affiliated with Angi (formerly Angie's List)".11 Federal Trade Commission, FTC Order Requires HomeAdvisor to Pay Up to $7.2 Million (January 2023)

The redirect. In November 2026, a request for the HomeAdvisor screening page, homeadvisor.com/screening, returned a permanent redirect to Angi's frequently asked questions page. A reader following an old link about HomeAdvisor's screening now lands on Angi's description of its own rules.22 Angi, Frequently Asked Questions

What we could not open. HomeAdvisor's home page presented an automated security check to our reader and no content. We did not find a current HomeAdvisor-hosted page setting out how its star ratings are calculated, who may review, or how reviews are moderated.

We are not going to fill that gap with what third-party marketing blogs say the rules are.

What the number means

What the number means on HomeAdvisor, as far as published sources allow
ItemStatus
Rating scaleNot confirmed from a current HomeAdvisor page
How the rating is calculatedThe platform does not disclose this on any page we could open
Who can leave a reviewNot confirmed
Screening of prosHomeAdvisor's screening address forwards to Angi's FAQ, which describes Angi's own checks
Whether Angi's review rules govern reviews shown under the HomeAdvisor nameNot stated on the pages we read

If you are looking at a pro on a HomeAdvisor-branded page, the practical move is to treat the stars as you would any undocumented score: read the reviews, check the count and dates, and verify the pro elsewhere.

Where the redirect leads

Since HomeAdvisor's screening address now points at Angi's FAQ, these are the rules a visitor is shown. They are Angi's statements about Angi.22 Angi, Frequently Asked Questions

  • Customers rate pros on a 1 to 5 star scale.
  • Anonymous reviews are not accepted, and the reviewer's name and address are visible to the provider.
  • Reviewers must confirm they are not affiliated with or competing against the company.
  • Feedback is checked before posting.
  • To be "Angi Approved", a business with at least one review must keep an average of 3 stars or higher, its owner, principal or relevant manager must pass a criminal background check, and it must attest to holding applicable licenses.
  • Approved pros pay to advertise and are listed above other providers.

Our Angi page covers these in detail.

The FTC order

The fullest public record of how HomeAdvisor operated is the FTC's case, which concerned the company's dealings with service providers, not consumer reviews.

The FTC filed its complaint in March 2022. It alleged that, since at least mid-2014, HomeAdvisor had made false, misleading or unsubstantiated claims to home service providers about:11 Federal Trade Commission, FTC Order Requires HomeAdvisor to Pay Up to $7.2 Million (January 2023)

  • Lead quality. That providers would receive leads matching the services they offered and the areas they served. The FTC alleged many leads did not.
  • Conversion. That leads resulted in jobs at rates the company could not substantiate.
  • Price. That the first month of an optional subscription product called mHelpDesk was free, when it cost $59.99.

Providers paid an annual membership fee of $287.99 plus a separate fee for each lead.

In January 2023 the Commission announced an order requiring HomeAdvisor to pay up to $7.2 million in redress, through two funds: up to $30 each for providers affected by the lead-quality claims, and up to $59.99 for those told the mHelpDesk month was free. The order prohibits misrepresentations about leads, including claims that leads come from people ready to hire. The vote to accept the agreement was 4 to 0.

Why a case about leads matters to someone reading reviews

It shows the business model. In a lead-generation marketplace, the homeowner's request is the product and the contractor is the buyer. The contractors who appear in response to a request are those who paid for the lead.

That does not make any individual pro worse. Plenty of good contractors buy leads. It means the list you are shown has been filtered by willingness to pay before it was sorted by anything else, and the stars beside each name sit on top of that filter. Thumbtack, which publishes its ranking factors, says openly that lead prices influence position.33 Thumbtack Help, How to improve my rank in search results

How to treat a HomeAdvisor rating

  1. Assume nothing about the formula. Without a published method you cannot know whether old reviews count fully or whether any reviews are excluded.
  2. Rely on the text and dates of the reviews. These are observable whatever the arithmetic.
  3. Check the same contractor on a platform with documented rules, such as Google, where the score is a stated average of published ratings.44 Google Business Profile Help, Understand review scores for local places and businesses
  4. Verify license and insurance with the state, as for any marketplace.

What would change this page

A current, HomeAdvisor-hosted policy page on ratings and reviews. If you know of one, send the address to corrections@ratingsdecoded.com and we will read it and revise.

Questions readers ask

Are HomeAdvisor and Angi the same company?

The FTC describes HomeAdvisor as affiliated with Angi. In November 2026, HomeAdvisor's screening address redirected to Angi's FAQ.11 Federal Trade Commission, FTC Order Requires HomeAdvisor to Pay Up to $7.2 Million (January 2023)

Did the FTC find HomeAdvisor's reviews were fake?

No. The FTC's case concerned representations made to service providers about leads and a subscription product, not consumer reviews.11 Federal Trade Commission, FTC Order Requires HomeAdvisor to Pay Up to $7.2 Million (January 2023)

How are HomeAdvisor star ratings calculated?

We could not find a current HomeAdvisor page that says. The platform does not disclose this in any source we were able to open.

Method We requested HomeAdvisor's own pages in November 2026. Its home page returned a bot-verification screen to our reader, and its screening address returned a permanent redirect to angi.com/faqs. This page reports only what we could confirm from that redirect, Angi's FAQ and the FTC's release. See how we source and check.

Sources

Every source below was opened and read for this page. Links go to the publisher's own copy.

  1. Federal Trade Commission. FTC Order Requires HomeAdvisor to Pay Up to $7.2 Million (January 2023)
  2. Angi. Frequently Asked Questions
  3. Thumbtack Help. How to improve my rank in search results
  4. Google Business Profile Help. Understand review scores for local places and businesses