RATINGS/DECODED

Platforms / HOUZZ

How Houzz professional reviews and its review policy work

Houzz's Review Policy requires that a review be based on first-hand experience as a client, not as a prospective client, and limits reviews to one person per household or company. Unusually, it permits incentivized reviews provided the incentive is clearly stated in the review itself. The policy does not explain how ratings are calculated.

Scale
Star reviews on professional profiles; scale and formula not stated in the policy
Formula
Not published in the Review Policy
Who can review
First-hand clients only; one person per household or company; no insiders, competitors or relatives
Filtering
Policy-based; reviewers agree to conditions when posting
Asking for reviews
Incentives permitted only if clearly disclosed in the review text

Houzz is a home design and remodeling platform where architects, designers, builders and trades keep profiles with project photos and client reviews. Its Review Policy is a single page framed as a list of things the reviewer agrees to by posting.11 Houzz Support, Review Policy

The conditions of posting

By posting a review, a user acknowledges and agrees to the following, in summary.

No insiders, competitors or relatives. The reviewer is not "a director, employee, officer, or principal" of the business reviewed or of a competitor, and is not "related in any way, including by blood, adoption or marriage" to the business or individual.

Clients only. The review is based on "first-hand experience as a client" and "not correspondence or interactions as a potential client".

Truthful. The review is "accurate, truthful and complete".

Within the Acceptable Use Policy. No libelous, defamatory, threatening, harassing or similar content, "as determined by Houzz in our sole and absolute discretion".

Incentives disclosed. "If you have received monetary compensation or other incentive to write and submit a Review, it will be clearly and conspicuously stated in the text of your Review, even if the amount or value of such incentive is small."

No payment demands. The reviewer will not use posting or removing a review "to demand payment", though "bona fide refund requests made in connection with a bad customer experience are acceptable".

No self-review. The reviewer is "not the professional being reviewed and using another profile".

About this company and this project. The review relates to a project with the professional "as stated in their Houzz profile" and makes no reference "to a different company, even if it has been rebranded".

No commentary on other reviews, no external links, no promotion of other companies.

One per household. "Only one person per household or company is reviewing the professional hired for the project."

Three rules that stand out

Prospects cannot review

On Thumbtack, a consumer who asked for a quote and heard nothing may leave a review about that.22 Thumbtack Help, Content and Review Policy On Houzz, the same person may not: an interaction "as a potential client" does not qualify.

The effect on a profile is predictable. Houzz reviews should contain fewer complaints about unanswered inquiries and quotes that seemed high, and proportionally more about completed projects. That makes the reviews more relevant to workmanship. It also removes a class of criticism that some customers care about. A designer who never returns calls will not be reviewed for it on Houzz.

Incentives are allowed if disclosed

Google, Yelp, Thumbtack and the BBB prohibit incentivized reviews.33 Google Maps Help, Prohibited and restricted content, Maps user-contributed content policy44 Yelp Support Center, Don't Ask for Reviews Houzz permits them subject to disclosure in the review text.

That position sits close to the federal baseline. The FTC rule bars incentives conditioned on a particular sentiment; staff guidance says incentives not tied to sentiment are allowed under the rule but should be disclosed.55 Code of Federal Regulations, 16 CFR 465.4, Buying positive or negative consumer reviews66 Federal Trade Commission, Consumer Reviews and Testimonials Rule: Questions and Answers Houzz's condition handles the disclosure. A professional who offered a reward only for positive reviews would still be on the wrong side of the federal rule regardless of what the reviewer disclosed.

For a reader, the practical step is to search a profile's reviews for phrases like "in exchange for" or "received a discount". Their presence is the system working. Their complete absence on a profile with many reviews tells you either that no incentives were offered or that none were disclosed, and you cannot distinguish the two.

The rebrand clause

The ban on references to "a different company, even if it has been rebranded" cuts in an interesting direction. A reviewer who knows that a contractor traded under another name, and had problems under it, may not say so in a Houzz review. A reader researching a firm should therefore check for earlier business names elsewhere, such as state licensing records, since Houzz reviews will not carry that history.

What the number means

What the number means on Houzz
You seeWhat the policy establishesWhat it leaves open
Rating on a pro's profileBuilt from client reviews that meet the policyScale, averaging method and any weighting are not in the policy
Review countOne reviewer per household or company per projectWhether all submitted reviews are published
A review with a disclosure lineThe reviewer received an incentive and said soThe size of the incentive, unless stated
No negative reviewsEither none were submitted or none met the policyWhich of the two

Removal and disputes

The policy is written as conditions on the reviewer, so a review that breaches a condition is open to challenge on that ground. Houzz reserves judgment on Acceptable Use violations to its "sole and absolute discretion". The page does not set out a dispute procedure, time limits or an appeal route.

What Houzz does not disclose on this page

  • How the star rating is calculated.
  • How it confirms that a reviewer was a client.
  • How many reviews it rejects or removes.
  • The process and timing for disputing a review.

Reading a Houzz profile

Houzz profiles are portfolio-first: the photos are the main exhibit and reviews support them. Because the policy narrows reviewers to actual clients and one per household, counts are likely to be small for a firm that completes a few projects a year. Apply small-sample caution accordingly. With eight reviews, a perfect 5.0 is unremarkable, as the table in is a perfect 5.0 suspicious shows.

Read for project detail: scope, duration, budget, how changes were handled. Those are things a real client knows and an invented one has to guess.

Questions readers ask

Can I review a Houzz pro I contacted but did not hire?

No. The policy requires first-hand experience as a client and excludes interactions as a potential client.11 Houzz Support, Review Policy

Does Houzz allow paid or incentivized reviews?

It allows a review where an incentive was received only if that is clearly and conspicuously stated in the review text.11 Houzz Support, Review Policy

Can two people from the same household review the same Houzz pro?

No. The policy allows one person per household or company to review the professional hired for a project.11 Houzz Support, Review Policy

Method Built from the Houzz Review Policy as published on Houzz Support, which carries a "last updated May 5, 2021" note. We found no Houzz page describing rating arithmetic or moderation statistics. See how we source and check.

Sources

Every source below was opened and read for this page. Links go to the publisher's own copy.

  1. Houzz Support. Review Policy
  2. Thumbtack Help. Content and Review Policy
  3. Google Maps Help. Prohibited and restricted content, Maps user-contributed content policy
  4. Yelp Support Center. Don't Ask for Reviews
  5. Code of Federal Regulations. 16 CFR 465.4, Buying positive or negative consumer reviews
  6. Federal Trade Commission. Consumer Reviews and Testimonials Rule: Questions and Answers